Maybe embedded is the wrong word. It certainly is a loaded word. It immediately reminds us of the reporters, the war correspondents, who are with our troops in Iraq and Afghanistan. These brave men and women, sometimes more than brave, return from their assignments and recount the hardships our men and women in uniform are enduring every day to keep us safe. Not quite as bravely, I have returned to recount what I saw on the front lines of the education wars.
I spent from September of 2009 to June of 2010 teaching English to tenth graders, fifteen year-olds, at Northeast High School in Philadelphia. As soon as the laughing abates over the obvious irony of a guy from Brooklyn teaching English, {one commentator said I wasn't qualified to be an English speaker let alone an English teacher}, there are things to report. I was there to teach but also to shoot a reality TV show. I know that taints the good intentions of the commitment but unlike most reality TV, which is often soft-scripted, this was a real attempt to see and show what it is like to be a first year teacher in an urban American high school. For me it was an eye-opener.
I arrived in Philly over the summer and went through the orientation and professional development seminars that are required of all first year teachers. At orientation, I found myself surrounded by hundreds of excited and exciting young people, ready to give their all for their students. I began to wonder, if this was representative of the majority of teachers in our schools, why is it that all we hear about are bad teachers and failing schools? Once school started I began to understand. The new movie about education, that is all the rage, is "Waiting For Superman." In the movie we see the gut-wrenching ordeal the parents go through to try to secure a spot at a good school for their children. They enter a lottery for the chance. It is heartbreaking to see one family cheering because they got into the high-performing school right next to a family in tears because they didn't. The movie makes a point of zeroing in on the teachers and their unions as a major part of the problem in our schools. I'm sure there are bad teachers. As there are less than competent people in all occupations. Look at politics. I'm also sure that teacher unions do try to protect their members. That's what unions do. The dilemma is that teaching is arguably the most important job there is and we can not, as a society, accept anything but the best when it comes to our kids and their education. Here's where I differ with the movie and the conventional wisdom. There are bad teachers but I believe there are more discouraged teachers. The fact that after three years, thirty percent of new teachers leave the profession and that at five years almost fifty percent move on to some other occupation seems to support the discouraged theory. Just as they are getting good at teaching they give up and leave. Why?
A few other questions come to mind. Would the majority of parents with children in our public schools put themselves and their kids through the ordeal the movie depicts. If there was a commitment from parents at large to make sure their children understand the importance of education and are prepared to learn when they get to school, wouldn't we be in a much better place? What effect does our culture at large have on our children and what is our individual responsibility. Someone once said," We want children to learn manners without ever seeing them." I remember even the cartoons we watched when we were kids had small bits of useful information. Bugs Bunny would play Beethoven or some historical figure or event would be referenced. Now the cartoons target our children, selling them products and turning them into consumers. There are violent video games, TV shows and movies that don't help either. Almost everyday I would tell my kids, "Good behavior will pay off." Then they would go home and watch "Jersey Shore" and come back and say, "No Mr. Danza, you're wrong, bad behavior pays off." And please don't blame the cast members, it's the upstanding suits that run these huge entertainment companies who are responsible for their programming.
Lastly, how about a little respect for the people who teach our children? A teacher's only real currency is their love of the job. It's hard to love a job that everyone derides. We all have a role in improving our schools. Teachers and their unions included. The status-quo is unacceptable but if a teacher has to teach the curriculum, build character, instill values and most importantly, teach self-control and self-discipline, all in a forty-five minute class, you better give the teacher a bit more time.
